Angela's Pizzeria
(0.65mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
192 Islip Ave,
Islip,
NY
(631) 581-9805
Fratelli Pizzeria
(0.84mi)Fast Food, Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
553 E Main St,
Bay Shore,
NY
(631) 666-0458
Vinnie's Mulberry Street
(1.10mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
42 W Main St,
East Islip,
NY
(631) 277-9500
Amore Pizza
(1.14mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
2110 Union Blvd,
Bay Shore,
NY
(631) 968-8181
Buseto Pizza
(1.44mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
1851 Sunrise Hwy,
Bay Shore,
NY
(631) 665-4939
Joe's Pasta & Pizza
(2.49mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
73 Howells Rd,
Bay Shore,
NY
(631) 665-2524
Route 27 Pizza
(2.50mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
3279 Sunrise Hwy North Service Rd,
Islip Terrace,
NY
(631) 277-4992
Mamma Santina Pizza
(2.87mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
201 Orinoco Dr,
Brightwaters,
NY
(631) 665-7880
Pita & Pizza
(3.88mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
1635 Islip Ave,
Central Islip,
NY
(631) 851-9292
Mannino's Restaurant + Lounge
(4.03mi)Italian
✓ Takeout
1575 New York 27A,
Oakdale,
NY
(631) 218-0909
Victorio II Pizza
(4.21mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
20 Bay Shore Rd,
Bay Shore,
NY
(631) 586-5552
Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta
(4.37mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
636 Union Blvd #3113,
West Islip,
NY
(631) 661-6246
La Mia's Pizzeria
(8.77mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
881 Montauk Hwy,
Bayport,
NY
(631) 868-7474
Central Pizza
(4.39mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
32 Wheeler Rd C,
Central Islip,
NY
(631) 582-4363
Anthony's Pizza & Pasta
(4.44mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
791 Udall Rd,
West Islip,
NY
(631) 321-4100
Cafe Europa Pizzeria & Restaurant
(4.58mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
504 Union Blvd,
West Islip,
NY
(631) 587-7000
Migueleño Restaurant & Pizza
(5.00mi)Italian, Spanish
✓ Delivery
146 Wheeler Rd,
Central Islip,
NY
(631) 582-1111
La Slice Pizzeria
(5.44mi)Italian, Pizza
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
1826 Veterans Memorial Hwy,
Islandia,
NY
(631) 778-6677