Key West Islip Beach
(4.76mi)American (Traditional)
✓ Takeout
600 S Bay Ave,
Islip,
NY
(631) 277-5500
Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering
(5.54mi)American (Traditional), Seafood
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
122 Ocean Ave,
Bay Shore,
NY
(631) 665-6262
Lala's Lounge
(5.55mi)American (Traditional), Pub Food
✓ Takeout
25 Bayview Ave,
Bay Shore,
NY
(631) 206-0420
Tullulah's
(6.24mi)American (New), American (Traditional), Tapas/Small Plates
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
12 4th Ave,
Bay Shore,
NY
(631) 969-9800
Changing Times American Sports Bar & Grille
(6.25mi)American (Traditional), Pub Food
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
29 E Main St,
Bay Shore,
NY
(631) 647-7871
Island Breeze
(6.29mi)American (Traditional), Seafood
✓ Takeout
178 Bayview Walk,
Cherry Grove,
NY
(631) 597-9111
Hometown Cafe
(6.61mi)American (Traditional), Breakfast & Brunch
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
104 E Main St,
East Islip,
NY
(631) 224-2766
Babylon Fish & Clam Restaurant
(6.75mi)American (Traditional), Italian, Seafood
✓ Takeout
458 Fire Island Ave,
Babylon,
NY
(631) 587-3633
Jackson Hall American Bar & Grille
(6.88mi)American (New), American (Traditional)
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
335 E Main St,
East Islip,
NY
(631) 277-7100
Grace Deli
(7.05mi)American (Traditional)
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
77 Howells Rd,
Bay Shore,
NY
(631) 647-4140
Farrell's of Brooklyn
(7.29mi)American (Traditional), Pub Food
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
263 Higbie Ln,
West Islip,
NY
(631) 482-1951
Cooper Street Grille
(7.29mi)American (Traditional)
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
217 E Main St,
Babylon,
NY
(631) 587-0159
Babylon Carriage House
(7.39mi)American (Traditional), Pub Food
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
21 Fire Island Ave,
Babylon,
NY
(631) 422-5161
Peter Pan Diner
(7.39mi)American (Traditional)
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
999 Sunrise Hwy,
Bay Shore,
NY
(631) 665-1788
Tricia's Cafe
(7.39mi)American (Traditional), Cafe Food
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
26 E Main St,
Babylon,
NY
(631) 422-7879
Glen's Dinette
(7.41mi)American (Traditional), Diners
✓ Takeout
23 E Main St,
Babylon,
NY
(631) 669-4700
Post Office Café
(7.48mi)American (Traditional), Cafe Food
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
130 W Main St,
Babylon,
NY
(631) 669-9224
Argyle Grill & Tavern
(7.48mi)American (New), American (Traditional)
✓ Takeout
+ ✓
Delivery
90 Deer Pk Ave,
Babylon,
NY
(631) 321-4900